OPS vs UPS vs NPS: Which Pension Scheme is Better?

The Indian government currently operates three major pension schemes:

  1. Old Pension Scheme (OPS) – Offers a guaranteed pension with DA benefits.
  2. Unified Pension Scheme (UPS) – Introduced in 2024, also provides guaranteed pension with family pension benefits.
  3. National Pension Scheme (NPS) – A market-linked pension plan where returns are not fixed and depend on investments.

If an employee’s last drawn basic salary is ₹90,000, OPS and UPS offer a fixed pension of ₹68,850 (with DA included), while NPS varies based on market returns.

1️⃣ Old Pension Scheme (OPS)

Guaranteed pension based on 50% of the last 10 months' average basic salary.
Dearness Allowance (DA) included, increasing over time.
No employee contribution required.
Not available for new employees (applicable only to those who joined before 2004).

Example Calculation:

  • If the last basic salary is ₹90,000, the pension is ₹45,000 + DA (53%) = ₹68,850/month.

2️⃣ Unified Pension Scheme (UPS)

Guaranteed pension based on 50% of the last 12 months’ average basic salary.
Minimum ₹10,000 pension for those with at least 10 years of service.
Family pension benefit (60% of pension amount to dependents).
DA included, similar to OPS.
Limited to central government employees.

Example Calculation:

  • With a ₹90,000 basic salary, the pension is ₹45,000 + DA (53%) = ₹68,850/month.

3️⃣ National Pension Scheme (NPS)

Market-linked pension – potential for higher returns.
Open to all employees, including private sector workers.
Tax benefits on investments.
No guaranteed pension – amount depends on investment returns.
Employees must contribute to the fund.

Example Calculation:

  • If an employee invests ₹10,000/month from age 30 to 60 (30 years), assuming an 8% annual return, the retirement corpus is ₹1.5 crore.
  • 40% of this corpus (₹60 lakh) is used for an annuity, generating an estimated ₹30,006/month pension (assuming a 6% return).

Comparison Table

Pension SchemePension CalculationMonthly Pension (₹90,000 Basic Salary)Total Pension (with 53% DA)
OPS (Old Pension Scheme)50% of last 10 months’ salary + DA₹45,000₹68,850
UPS (Unified Pension Scheme)50% of last 12 months’ salary + DA₹45,000₹68,850
NPS (National Pension Scheme)Market-based (investment dependent)₹30,006 (approx.)Varies with market returns

Which Pension Scheme is Best?

  • OPS & UPS provide higher, guaranteed pension with DA benefits, making them better for government employees.
  • NPS is riskier but flexible, suitable for private-sector employees or those willing to invest in the market.

If job security and a fixed pension are priorities, OPS or UPS is the better choice. If market-based growth and investment flexibility appeal to you, NPS might be the right fit.